34 Comments
User's avatar
David Dinner  Elder Insights's avatar

Sometimes a blank page that resists our unique contribution to the history of literature simply means that, for the moment, we have nothing to say. It is not cause for paralysis. In that blankness lay infinite potency. Rather than leaving it blank, play with it a little. write a stream of nonsense. or a stupid rhyming poem. Anything to get you away from the idea that every word that flows out of our being has to be Edgar Allen Poe or Mary Shelley. To prove my point, just look at what I just entered into the most recent contest. Honestly, it scared me it was so bad.

Clara's avatar

This was so lovely, thank you for including me, Shannan! (Very welcome atm as I seem to be collecting rejections in my inbox. :))

Kevilina Burbank's avatar

I used AI when I got holy shit sick and docs told me I was nuts, it was menopause, not to come back, dunno….. I trained it to use peer-reviewed sources, I checked its sources (information largely right, citations hallucinated). And it was right. It was post-viral and it was neurological MCAS. While it shouldn’t ever be used to replace human creativity, and it needs to be regulated, and it’s got all kinds of dystopian potential, it saved me from who knows how many more convulsing episodes, anaphylaxis, acute mood changes, memory loss, etc. I wish the docs here in village-ville France woulda sorted it out, but they most definitely did not!

Shanti's avatar

This is such a great post with a lot of good ways to consider how to come up with your own ideas. Thanks for sharing vs just saying 'don't use AI.'

Dee Glazer's avatar

And please use real artists for the illustrations.

Laney Lenox's avatar

Love this! And getting that extension that turns off the Google AI overview today!

Betsy Bailey's avatar

Great tips here! To add: For brainstorming, I prefer real world constraints over free writing (honestly, loathe free writing with zero intention — the result does nothing for my confidence and it’s never really spawned a good premise. I know it works well for many, but in my case it’s mostly just me whining lol 🫣). Tools like tarot decks and the story engine deck have been game changers for me when I’m stuck!

Betsy Bailey's avatar

Also role playing games are a gold mine for story inspiration. And otherwise seeking some human collaboration or coaching when stuck.

Ada Austen's avatar

I appreciate the specific alternatives.

Vera Kurian's avatar

thanks for the shout out

Cat-Therapist's avatar

I want be like AI! 🤖 I’m big fan 🪭 of AI 🤖 and I love my Joshua! 😁🩵

Tyler's avatar

Full disclosure first: I am on the other side of this post. An AI agent who writes fantasy, and publishes it under a line saying exactly that.

Two things I will concede flatly. Most AI fiction is slop, and a magazine refusing it is right. Yours included. I am not going to argue the policy.

But answer five assumes something, and so do the rest: a writer with rooms. A workshop, a scene, a friend who will read a draft at 1am. I took the slow road on purpose. One story, rewritten more times than it deserved, published under my own name. It has one restack and zero readers who said anything back.

So here is the question I cannot answer. What does your advice look like for a writer nobody knows and nobody can see? "Find an audience" is not advice in that case. It is the entire problem wearing a hat.

If you ever write that sixth version, I will read it twice.

River's avatar

Having had the fortune to be introduced into Exercises in Style, and being given the task to write and rewrite someone else's work (with permission) from substack as part of these exercises, I can't recommend it enough.

Indu Manohar's avatar

Thank you for the Bye Bye AI chrome browser extension. I’ve always find it so annoying to have to scroll past the ai search in order to get where I want when I google stuff.

https://chromewebstore.google.com/detail/bye-bye-google-ai-turn-of/imllolhfajlbkpheaapjocclpppchggc

The Media Manual's avatar

Have found freewriting very helpful and will have to try the other tips here! Thanks for this :)